Why Charcoal May Endanger Somalia’s Best Hope for Peace

  • Share
  • Read Later
STUART PRICE / AFP / Getty Images

Somali youths pull donkey-drawn water carts past sacks of charcoal on the side of the road as the African Union Mission in Somalia soldiers make their way through the Somali city of Kismayo on Oct. 2, 2012

On a Monday afternoon in October, in a warehouse in the southern Somali port of Kismayo, I attended a meeting on the future of Somalia. On one side: 20 Somali traders sitting on grass mats and wearing sandals, sarong-like wraps, short-sleeved shirts and embroidered scarves. On the other, in plastic chairs: officers from the Kenyan and Somali armies and the allied militia Ras Kamboni Brigades, who, fighting under the banner of the African Union Mission in Somalia (AMISOM), ousted the al-Qaeda-allied al-Shabab from southern Somalia’s biggest city a few weeks earlier. AMISOM’s offensive against al-Shabab, kicking them out of the capital Mogadishu in August last year and then capturing Kismayo, were a body blow to the Islamists and represent the best chance for peace in Somalia since the collapse of the last central government in 1991. But in Kismayo, as I discovered, as the only Western journalist to enter the city, the joy of victory had quickly soured. At stake at the October meeting, I was told, was nothing less than peace in southern Somalia, and possibly the whole country. And the key? A giant pile of burnt, dead wood.

Great progress has been made in Somalia over the past 15 months. Al-Shabab has suffered a series of military setbacks, a new Somali President has been chosen, a slimline government has been formed, famine has abated and Mogadishu is enjoying a newfound optimism after decades of destruction. The turnaround seems dramatic and it is, given 21 years of war and famine. But the truth is that while those tragedies gave the world an impression of a failed state without hope, for many Somalis, the enduring reality of daily life during the fighting — and at the heart of many of Somalia’s conflicts — was always business. Camel trading, mango growing, mobile telecoms and, of course, arms dealing all thrived in the war years. And few businesses were as big or profitable, or as tough, as charcoal.

(PHOTOS: Somalia in Transition)

The charcoal business grew exponentially under al-Shabab. While the group did not itself invest directly in charcoal, it levied taxes at every stage of the process, from production to export. U.N. investigators reckoned the group earned $25 million from the trade last year. So in February the U.N. banned charcoal exports in a bid to cut off funding for al-Shabab. Since then, charcoal has been piling up. There are now more than 4 million sacks of the stuff at Kismayo’s southern entrance, stacked in immense house-sized blocks of dirty burlap bags lining the soot-covered road. Its value is estimated at up to $40 million.

A boon to a postconflict economy, perhaps? Anywhere but Somalia. Matt Bryden, director of the Nairobi-based think tank Sahan Research and a former coordinator of the U.N. Monitoring Group on Somalia and Eritrea, which analyzed the charcoal trade, said a handful of traders controlled the trade and all of them had commercial, if not necessarily ideological, links to al-Shabab. “There’s no question that this is an al-Shabab-linked industry and those relationships don’t evaporate overnight,” he said. One Western diplomat with close knowledge of the situation told me that any sale of charcoal, even the relatively small amounts already known to be leaving Kismayo, means “the financial circuit has not been interrupted. The major financing for al-Shabab continues.”

All of which might make a resumption of the trade sound like a bad idea. But the businessmen, and some of al-Shabab’s enemies — all of them well armed — disagree. The city was captured partly with the aid of Ras Kamboni Brigades, an ethnic-Ogadeni-clan militia run by Sheik Ahmed Madobe. Madobe is a tall, bearded warlord who has himself undergone a remarkable rebirth. Five years ago he was an Islamist commander targeted by American missiles. Today he is a crucial ally in the war on al-Qaeda in Somalia. He wants the charcoal trade restarted. “The economy of this city is 90% charcoal,” Madobe told me. “Businessmen have invested a lot of their money and the U.N. embargo is blocking it. The stockpile cannot be returned to the trees. It should be sold.”

(MORE: Somalia’s Chance: Can a U.S.-Backed African Force Bring Peace?)

The dispute could have ramifications for attempts to install Somalia’s first central government in generation. Negotiations to determine the makeup of a post-Shabab southern administration, under way for a year without resolution, are now on hold, pending resolution of the charcoal dispute. As for attempts by the national government to establish its rule, earlier this month Madobe refused to meet a presidential delegation sent to Kismayo, issuing a scarcely veiled threat that he could not guarantee their safety if they entered the city. Says Bryden: “[This is] about power and resource sharing in the Jubas [the collective name for Somalia’s three southern regions]. People are looking at that big stack of charcoal and they want the profit.”

Some discern a nefarious international hand at work as well. Control of Kismayo means control of southern Somalia’s economy — and well-established, lucrative smuggling routes into Kenya, taking charcoal out and sugar in. With elections due in Kenya early next year, some suspect Kenyan politicians and military leaders of reopening the trafficking routes to feed their political slush funds. During my time in Kismayo, a trip to the port revealed Kenyan and Ras Kamboni soldiers overseeing the unloading of cement from a cargo ship and, from the fat bellies of two wooden dhows, timber, pasta, cooking oil and sugar. The dispute over Kismayo’s mountain of charcoal may endure for a while yet. But in the end, as it did through two decades of war, there seems little doubt that one way or another Somali business will triumph.

MORE: Dispatch from Somalia: War, but a Glimmer of Hope

Sort: Newest | Oldest

Mathew Bryden has gone "native." He is deeply involved in Somali clan politics and he always comes in on the side of his "in laws" since he is married to lady from the Isaq clan of northern Somalia. Since the civil war in northern Somlia in 1988 the Isaq are bitter enemies of the Darod of Puntland and jubaland (where Kismayo is located), and mathew Bryden uses his Canadian looks to harm the Darod as much as he can. He was, allegedly, let go of the UN monitoring group, after he attacked the last president, prime minister and chairman of the somali parliament in a report that said they stole millions of aid money. The reason for the attack? The Isaq clan wants to secede from the rest of Somalia to form their own state known as Somaliland. The leaders in Mogadishu were opposed to the plan. Eeven the name of his think tank Sahan is Somali for survey.

The idea that money from the charcoal will go to Al-shabaab is absurd.  It is designed to crush the local economy, demoralize the population, and cripple the new administration in Kismayo. The charcoal that is already there is not going back to the trees. The only sensible option is to lift the embargo and let the locals recoup their investments, so that they can start different busineses. The embargo was designed to stop the terrorists from getting cash by destroying the forests, not to harm those who are fighting them.


I dont think you should quote Matt Bryden as he was FIRED from the UN for have bias views against the somali people and how he encourages people to lose faith in the somali people even though the somali people haven't lost faith in themselves


I don't quite understand where all the wood necessary to make charcoal is coming from.  Somalia is one of the drier regions of the world and is only about 10.8% forested. If the locals are cutting these trees to make charcoal, it will only accelerate desertification of the area.  The forests, such as they are, are all located in the southwestern area of the country adjacent to the Kenyan boarder.  Cutting off the sales of charcoal may actually be the best thing for Somalia's ecology in the long run.