India’s Ruling Coalition Grants Itself a Good Report Card

The 92-page report is an attempt to sell the Congress-led coalition before next year's election. The opposition isn't buying it

  • Share
  • Read Later
MANISH SWARUP / AFP / Getty Images

Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, second from left, looks on as the ruling United Progressive Alliance chairperson Sonia Gandhi greets people during the release of the coalition's self-assessment report at a function in New Delhi on May 22, 2013

A renascent and inclusive economy, better governance, better distribution of welfare programs and improved relations with neighbors — these, claims India’s ruling United Progressive Alliance (UPA) coalition, are the four cornerstone achievements of the past nine years. Its 92-page report for the period, released Wednesday evening, is an unabashed attempt to sell the Congress-led coalition to the electorate before the country goes to the polls next year. “We can legitimately claim, and with pride, that the UPA government has taken our country forward on all these four fronts in the nine years,” said Prime Minister Manmohan Singh. “We have journeyed many miles, though we know we have more miles ahead.”

But while it effusively sang its own praises, the scandal-prone coalition raised eyebrows for its platitudinous treatment of the corruption cases that have occurred during its tenure, most notoriously the 2G-spectrum scandal, in which mobile-phone companies were allocated cut-price frequency licenses, leading to an estimated $32 billion shortfall in the country’s exchequer. Singh said the problems were being “dealt with, as they should be, under the law,” and claimed that the “perceived nontransparency in the manner of allocation has been addressed and these problems will not arise in the future.”

(MORE: India’s States of Excellence)

The report also focused on India’s rise as a global power. It said under the leadership of the UPA, India was “able to manage some very difficult challenges,” like its relations with China. It doesn’t, however, talk about its failure to force Pakistan into making headway in the investigation into the 2008 Mumbai attacks or the fact that traditional allies like the Maldives and Sri Lanka are getting closer to China.

The slowdown of the Indian economy was meanwhile blamed on external factors such as the global economy and tight monetary policy at home to control inflation, which had touched double digits in the past couple of years. While the report discusses inflation at length, it mentions the creation of jobs only in passing, saying that the services sector has continued to grow at 9% creating good-quality jobs. However, if a 2011 report by Crisil research is believed, India needs at least 55 million additional jobs by 2015 to maintain the current ratio of employed people to total population at 39%. “When you add to [inflation and unemployment] the brazen corruption you have seen in the recent past, it is a recipe for disaster,” says Paranjoy Guha Thakurta, a Delhi-based independent political analyst. He called the report “a desperate attempt to refurbish an image for a party and a coalition, staring defeat in the next general elections.”

(MORE: After Fighting Over Mountains, India and China Lock Horns in the Indian Ocean)

It certainly didn’t convince the opposition, Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), who called it a “nonreport” and said it hid all the scams, revealing “only the convenient.” The BJP also criticized Singh’s leadership, alleging that he is a symbolic leader who leads the Cabinet while the real leadership lies with UPA chairperson Sonia Gandhi. “He is neither leader of his party nor the country,” Sushma Swaraj, BJP’s leader of opposition in the Lok Sabha, told reporters. “This divided leadership is leading to uncertainty in the country.”

The BJP also published its own charge sheet against the UPA government’s “failures,” alleging that the UPA has not been deterred by scandals and has interfered in federal investigations. Sectors like telecom, power, national highways, rural roads, seaports, according to the BJP charge sheet, suffered a serious setback, while inflation has continued to cause misery.

(MORE: What Must India Do to Realize Its Economic Potential? Think Big. Act Bold)

The Indian media were similarly scathing in their criticism of what they called a “self-congratulatory” report. An editorial in the Indian newspaper DNA called the report a “poor defence, an unconvincing rationalisation” of the government’s performance. “[The people] are not going to buy the sales pitch of a government that has been hobbling under the burden of successive scams for the last four years,” the editorial said. “The good the UPA did was rewarded. Now, it is time to accept the reprimand for its acts of omission and commission in the second term, and with no hard feelings.”

The UPA’s second term started off on a high note, with education becoming a right for children ages 6 to 14. The passing of the antigraft bill and the decision to allow foreign investment in multibrand retail were also lauded as steps forward. And yet, much of the term has been characterized by policy paralysis. With a year to go before the general elections, the coalition will need to get moving on its flagship programs, particularly the food-security bill. The bill, which aims to alleviate hunger, could help win back the support of India’s poor and middle class, a key to keeping power in 2014.

PHOTOS: India Scorched by Blistering Heat Wave

4 comments
vaishnavjagdip
vaishnavjagdip

Political calculations shall ruin India, Indian economy & sufferers shall be common man

Consider when indian economy is not in good state, when fiscal & current account deficit are high, when contingent liabilities are visible , when public distribution system is in mess, how Govt can even think to pass Food security bill?

One side ,govt reduces subsidy burden, raises price of petrol, diesel, coking gas, electricity, public transport etc which troubles common man other side want to pass Food security bill which shall gain increase subsidy burden.Indian economy shall be ruined,if food security bill gets through 

jvaishnav47
jvaishnav47

                                                                  INDIA'S   REPORT CARD --

Corruption is rampant, crime rate is increasing,conviction rate falling down ,judicial process takes undue long time which amounts to justice delayed is justice denied.

All big scams have taken place under the nose of the Govt, however highlighted by CAG ,CVC,LOKAYUKTA. Govt is failed to recover anything as yet , from nabbed on. charges of big scams.

Intelligence agencies have not shown good result,hence India could not avert terror attacks, even culprits are not traced out. So many scams could not be stopped.

Govt believes in retaining power at the cost of 'public interest" however govt must realize, real achievement is   'public satisfaction"

One side farmers are committing suicide, children die due to malnutrition all due to poverty ,other side scams after scams, deficit governance

have siphoned billions of tax payers /public money .This applies to govt ,irrespective of any political parties                                                         

sridhar.sid
sridhar.sid

BJP's criticism of the UPA report card is predictable! They have done only one thing well in the last four years and that is to disrupt Parliament. This is an opposition party that cannot muster enough votes to bring the Government down and hence has been fighting UPA in TV studios. BJP is irrelevant to the young restless Indians who care more about growth and jobs and less about Hindutva, which is a baggage the BJP can never shed. For its part, the UPA lost the plot in 2009, when growth rates in the UPA 1 term was so impressive that they never planned for the worst. The world economy collapsed due to the failure in the banking sector and India was left scrambling. Add to this, some corrupt politicians found it too tempting to scoop the loot. In spite of all this, the UPA has shown resilience and also put India on the world map for which they can feel proud. In this coalition Government climate, the UPA has done a creditable job for India